Gary L. Simmons  rev 07/07/03  http://battlecatslitterbox.com/Anvil/HAS/Trojan.html
Litterbox  Anvil Tips  Hamish Sanderson's EditNotes


The Battle Cat's Litterbox


Regarding Requests to Port Trojan to AO Mac/SDL
(or anything else)



The absolute final answer on this subject is "Sorry, but NO".

No permission has ever been given (I've already been asked twice before). No permission will ever be given. [And if anyone ever tried to do it without permission they would find their hide being skinned off them by yours truly the moment I found out about it.]

I've various reasons for my position here, though I don't particularly desire to go into them because it's not really all that riveting. Put simply, however:

I am unwilling (and unable) to devote any more time to Marathon. If I allowed anyone to port TM1/TM2, I would have to personally check and approve the results in order to give permission for it to be released. That would take time. I would also need access to a Linux or Windows box to test [an SDL port] on, and I have neither. And there is absolutely no way I'd give permission on something like this sight unseen.


Now, TM2/Mac could have happened at one point, but, for various reasons, in the end it did not. Life contains many disappointments, but I would suggest this is very much a minor one and not something to get particularly upset about.

However - and let's be absolutely clear here, - even though I'm no longer around in person I still have a responsibility to the work I've left behind, and towards the folk who worked on Trojan in particular. I passed up a perfectly good opportunity for personal attention and glory after all, as I could not in conscience release TM2 for Mac because doing so would have meant dumping over TM1's music authors like I couldn't care less for them. And it's why I won't permit any third-party ports either. I can't take responsibility for a port I can't (and won't) be involved in; therefore the only solution is not to allow ports, period.


There are two versions of Trojan already available: one for M1/Mac, one for M2/Win. Of those, TM1/Mac is the 'definitive' version; the one I will point to whenever Trojan is mentioned and say "I did that". The M2/Win version is a slightly crippled port that I did because I thought it would be a nice gesture towards the M2/Win crowd to give them something nice [albeit a little clunky] to play with, and because I could.

I'm aware that the Marathon community itself has moved slightly beyond those bounds since, but I'm afraid there's nothing I can do about that. I'm happy at the contribution I made; I did five years and then moved on to new things. And, for better or worse, I am content to let it stand as-is.

I hope folks will appreciate my position on this. Besides, I'm certain folk can manage to find plenty more productive ventures to occupy themselves than this old flogged horse...:)

Best regards,

has

Top of page

Back to the Litterbox